Last December, the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) issued a public call for feedback to “better inform the Commission’s understanding” of the Ethereum network and the cryptocurrency ether.
Now CFTC Chairman Heath Tarbert, who just took over the role in July, has come to a decision on its status. Tarbert believes ether (ETH) is a commodity, and thus falls under the jurisdiction of the CFTC. He also anticipates ether futures trading on U.S. markets in the near future.
“We’ve been very clear on bitcoin: bitcoin is a commodity. We haven’t said anything about ether—until now,” Tarbert said on stage at Yahoo Finance’s All Markets Summit in New York City on Thursday. “It is my view as chairman of the CFTC that ether is a commodity.”
Tarbert agrees with the SEC’s previous guidance that bitcoin and ether are not securities. And he says the CFTC is working with the SEC on these issues.
The CFTC first stated that it views “bitcoin and other virtual currencies” as commodities back in 2015 (long before the SEC did), buried in a filing when it brought charges against a company called Coinflip. But this is the first time the CFTC has given guidance on ether.
Tarbert acknowledges “ambiguity in the market” on the status of many coins, but says that ultimately “similar digital assets should be treated similarly.”
Perhaps most interestingly, Tarbert says that “forked” assets—cryptocurrencies like bitcoin cash (BCH), bitcoin gold (BTG), and ethereum classic (ETC), coins created via forks from the original underlying blockchain—should be treated by regulators the same as the original asset. In other words, the CFTC’s classification of each coin depends on how the coin was created.
“It stands to reason that similarly assets should be treated similarly. If the underlying asset, the original digital asset, hasn’t been determined to be a security and is therefore a commodity, most likely the forked asset will be the same,” Tarbert said, “unless the fork itself raises some securities law issues under that classic Howey Test.”
The “Howey Test” refers to a 1946 case involving the selling of shares in a citrus grove that the SEC now uses as its north star in determining whether a digital currency behaves like a security. SEC director of corporate finance Bill Hinman, speaking at Yahoo Finance’s All Markets Summit: Crypto in San Francisco in June of last year, explained that newly created tokens are likely securities because they are marketed with “the promise that the assets will be cultivated in a way that will cause them to grow in value, to be sold later at a profit,” and “typically are sold to a wide audience rather than to persons who are likely to use them on the network.”
Bitcoin and ether, on the other hand, Hinman and the SEC see as sufficiently decentralized and not controlled by a third party “whose efforts are a key determining factor in the enterprise.” Thus Hinman determined that sales of bitcoin and ether are not securities transactions.
CFTC Chairman Tarbert was asked on stage by Yahoo Finance’s Scott Gamm whether the Howey Test is really relevant anymore in 2019. He says it is: “I think the analysis is pretty sound. It has stood the test of time. Ultimately it goes to the fundamental question: is this something that is being used for capital raising, and are you investing in an enterprise, or are you buying something that has tangible store of value in and of itself?”
Tarbert also gave insight on how he and the CFTC view coins created through initial coin offerings (ICOs). He believes it is possible for a new coin to start out as a security but eventually become a commodity. “You can have a situation where something in an initial coin offering is a security initially, but over time, it gets more decentralized, and there’s a tangible value there, so you can have things that change back and forth.”
Tarbert’s comments come one day after the IRS issued its first new crypto tax guidance in five years, specifying that cryptocurrencies created from a fork should be handled as “ordinary income equal to the fair market value of the new cryptocurrency when it is received,” which matches what it has said about bitcoin.
In other words, it would appear that multiple government agencies are thinking about forked cryptocurrencies right now.
Earlier this week, Tarbert’s CFTC predecessor Christopher Giancarlo said in an interview with crypto site The Block that he expects crypto policy will “get serious” this year. “2019 is the year in which there’s a growing recognition that regulators and policy makers need to do more than just be aware of these, but may actually need to look at some policy responses,” Giancarlo said. “And I think the thing driving that in 2019 is a combination of Libra and the prospects for central bank digital currencies.”
Indeed, the coin community is watching closely the developments in Facebook’s attempt to launch cryptocurrency Libra, which has faced backlash from lawmakers. Last week, PayPal, one of 28 “founding members” of the Libra Association, dropped out.
After Hinman of the SEC issued his opinion on ether last year at the Yahoo Finance summit, cryptocurrency bulls breathed a collective sigh of relief; the price of ether surged. Tarbert’s clarity on ether and on forked assets could cause crypto prices to pop for a short time, if the past is any indication.
Daniel Roberts covers bitcoin and blockchain at Yahoo Finance. Follow him on Twitter at @readDanwrite.